Halaman

    Social Items

Showing posts with label Car Plants. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Car Plants. Show all posts


Mitsubishi operate a car plant in the southeast of the Netherlands called Nedcar, which they took over fully from Volvo in 2001. Prior to that it was joint owned. Mitsubishi now want to end its production there and are asking a token 1 Euro for its purchase. Production is down to only 50,000 cars, the 1,500 workers making the Colt and Outlander models. Mitsubishi's European sales have dropped sharply of late due to the strength of the Yen and a generally uncompetitive product lineup. Mitsubishi cars in Europe will be imported from Japan and Thailand, where the company is building a new plant.

To me the real issue here is that they are essentially moving production from Europe to Thailand. Mitsubishi either had to increase production in Holland (as 50k production for two models isn't going to make money) or utilise the new Thai plant. It looks like plan two won the day. It is no doubt the more profitable decision but you have to feel for the 1,500 workers that lose their jobs.

Car Plant For One Euro


Below is an article about Dutch car plant Nedcar in Born. To see the problem, production figures give it away. When the plant was shared, production volume made it viable. Now down to one brand and possibly one model, it would never pay. To show what I mean, production figures for the plant when Mitsubishi joined production:

Yr Total Mitsub Volvo smart
95 100,400 20,900 79,500 -
96 145,200 44,500 100,700 -
97 197,200 82,200 115,000 -
98 243,000 92,000 151,000 -
99 262,200 112,900 149,300 -
00 215,100 58,800 156,300 -
01 189,300 67,200 122,100 -
02 176,000 70,200 105,800 -
03 163,100 73,900 89,200 -
04 187,600 87,000 28,000 72,600
05 115,100 68,100 - 47,000
06 87,300 73,200 - 14,100
07 61,900 61,900 - -
08 59,200 59,200 - -
09 50,600 50,600 - -
10 48,000 48,000 - -

Since it came down to one brand, things were not good. Expand or close? I don't see any future for the plant, not in car making anyway.

Nedcar Production History: 1995-2010


I wrote this article in December 2009: http://tiny.cc/BVGf2b
Just over two years later little has been done about European overcapacity. Both Fiat and GM closed a plant in 2011, but that was not enough by far. GM and PSA are trying to save costs with a cooperation deal as I mentioned in a recent article. That will achieve little if they both fail to bite the bullet and close factories. So what is the problem?

The Problem: Depressed Sales. Europe is in a financial squeeze and the brands hurting are the makers of standard, everyday cars. Premium brands are doing fine.
The Reaction So Far: Slash prices to try keep people buying cars. With no end in sight to the economic woes, this means big losses.
What To Do: Reduce capacity. Not too much though as any future economic improvement needs to be met, but enough to get operating costs down.
Why It Hasn't Happened: It is a very unpopular thing to do. Politicians get involved when plant closures get mentioned and government meddling always makes things worse.
Those Most Affected: Fiat, PSA, Renault and GM Opel/Vauxhall.
To Be Done: Some car plants in France need to close, another in Italy for Fiat and one GM plant (obviously one of the three German plants). This is a minimum.
Will It Happen?: It has to, but how it is handled will say much about Europe.

The European Car Making Mess


Ford just posted another loss in Europe, $149m this time. GM loses money each year. Yet both are popular within the region, 2nd and 3rd respectively according to ACEA. GM knows it needs to close a plant at least, one of the three in Germany would be obvious. I'm less sure what Ford should do. Close its Belgium plant and move Mondeo production elsewhere? PSA, Renault and Fiat all have far too much capacity. They all need to close plants in their home nations.

All these companies have a common problem. European politics. Companies need to run profitable businesses or they will eventually fail. Governments know that closing a car plant is bad publicity. Politicians only think of the next election and getting voted back in. Each year the Koreans use their profits to make better cars. The Chinese brands are getting better. If Japanese brands make more cars offshore and become more profitable, then they will make a comeback too.

In the meantime, European operations will slip back as R&D is cut back, quality suffers and market share is eroded. Of course the 'here today and gone tomorrow' politicians won't be worried about that. They kept the short sighted public happy and got reelected. No wonder things in Europe are a mess.

Plant Closures In Europe...Not

Yes, they make cars in this alpine country, thanks to a Canadian owned company named Magna Steyr. All cars made here are from this company, made for other companies. In fact, it is the largest contract manufacturer for vehicles in the world. So how did things pan out on 2011:
MINI Countryman 89,000 +260%
BMW X3 17,900 -44%
Peugeot RCZ 13,700 _29%
M Benz SLS AMG/G-Class 7,200 +31%
Aston Martin Rapide 1,500 +0%

Total 129,300 +46%

Chrysler has just ceased making cars in Austria after many years. The X3 has finished I believe and the Rapide goes to the UK about now. Production was 209,000 in 2004, but by building for other car makers makes the whole operation subject to fluctuations. That accepted, it has done well to maintain as much consistency as it has.

Car Production Austria: 2011


In Europe, car workers have a vacation in August, and usually return to meet orders and bolster supply. For some workers not this year. They are being told to continue their break and expect production cuts for the foreseeable future as well. This affects Peugeot, Citroen, Fiat, Renault Ford and General Motors plants. All these brands make volume brands, not premium marques.

The problem(s): The protracted Eurozone crisis is dampening demand, although the large markets of Germany, the UK and Russia are holding up quite well. So the real problem is over capacity, so that as soon as demand is soft, inventories grow and profits evaporate.
Why some makes are coping: Premium brands are selling well still. Plants that export a sizable amount of cars to areas outside of Europe are partially buffered. For example the Nissan Qashqai and Juke, Honda Civic Hatch and Toyota Avensis come to countries like Australia and NZ from the UK.
Any solutions?: A few factories should close, without government intervention and meddling. Can some production be sent outside of the Eurozone? The low Euro would certainly help, although it takes time develop export markets.
The reality: Europe should be moving away from so much dependence on cars anyway, to improve quality of life. Added to that, the days of constant improvement of living standards are over. Car makers, politicians and the public at large must accept that. Car makers need to meet demand and this will cost jobs. If that rather obvious reality is accepted and car makers can rationalise their businesses as they see fit, then the sooner it is done the better. Dilly dallying will weaken these companies in the meantime.

Car Workers Told To Stay At Home


It seems that Ford is to close it's Belgian Ford plant in Genk, which makes Mondeos and S-Max models. This will mean the loss of over 4,000 jobs. Production of the new Mondeo and S-Max will got to Valencia, Spain. Also on the chopping block is the Southampton factory, which makes the Transit van and 500 jobs will go. Most Transit vans are made in Turkey anyway, so this will be seamless. (Since it has been announced the stamping plant in Dagenham is to go too).

To summarise: The decision had to be made and it will hurt thousands of workers. It probably should have happened a few years ago but the hope was things would return to normal in Europe. It is now understood 'normal' is a long way off, or perhaps never to return. I feel for the workers and their families but it had to be done sometime.
Meanwhile over in France, PSA (Peugeot & Citroen) has been given a 7bn euros state handout (er, I mean guarantee) to help it through difficult times. However, the French government wants PSA to reduce job losses and I assume not to close a factory.

To Summarise: No one wants to see thousands of workers lose their jobs, but Peugeot has too much capacity. Surely this decision only delays the inevitable...but perhaps the economic woes in Europe are in fact only temporary. Yeah, right.
 Pic: AFP/Kristof van Accom

Ford To Close Factories, Peugeot Non?

It's no secret that there is an over capacity in car plants in Europe. Drastic decisions need to be made. Two cases are in the forefront right now.
GM Opel: GM want to stop making cars in Bochum Germany by 2016 but continue running it as a parts distribution centre. Obviously this will affect job numbers. GM wants workers to accept a turn around plan by February 2012 or they will be forced to shut Bochum by the end of 2014. GM Europe will lose 1.5 billion US$ this year alone.
It seems GM feels isn't getting the speedy co-operation it needs. A works council   and union representatives describe the threat to close sooner as unacceptable.

My take: GM has decided to finish car production in Bochum. It is losing too much money. So why so long to close it? It needs to asap. I normally sympathise with workers losing jobs. However, Germany has avoided any pain in this regard while factories have closed elsewhere. Companies have been scared to stand up to Germany. GM are, and its time to accept that is has to happen even in 'not in our backyard' Germany.

Renault: This is a brand that needs to act to regain a healthy balance sheet again. It too is getting frustrated trying to get worker concessions in order to improve competitiveness. It said it wouldn't close factories if the above was achieved. Renault has now said if those needed measures cannot be achieved, two plants would be closed.

My take: Another example of a company desperately needing to become more competitive and feeling a lack of will from Unions. An aide to Industry Minister said it resembled blackmail. It could also be called spelling out what will need to be done if this situation is not resolved soon.
Overall: Desperate times need desperate measures. Buying time is not an option when there is no sign of improvement for the foreseeable future. There are difficult times in Europe but a lack of will in changing things is not an option.

Car Plants Struggle In Europe